What is Critical Appraisal?

 

Critical appraisal is the process of carefully and systematically assessing the outcome of scientific research (evidence) to judge its trustworthiness, value and relevance in a particular context. Critical appraisal looks at the way a study is conducted and examines factors such as internal validity, generalizability and relevance. Some initial appraisal questions you could ask are:

 

1. Is the evidence from a known, reputable source?

2. Has the evidence been evaluated in any way? If so, how and by whom?

3. How up-to-date is the evidence?

 

Second, you could look at the study itself and ask the following general appraisal questions:

 

1. Did the study address a clearly focused issue?

2. Is the study design appropriate to the stated aims?

3. Are the measurements likely to be valid and reliable?

4. Are the statistical methods described?

5. How large was the effect size?

6. How precise was the estimate of the effect (look for the confidence intervals!)

7. Could there be confounding?

8. What implications does the study have for your practice? Is it relevant?

9. Can the results be applied to your organization?

10. Is the intervention feasible in your organization?

 

 

Critical Appraisal Questionnaires

 

ChecklistFor appraisal questions (checklists) for specific study designs, see:

 

Appraisal of a controlled study

Appraisal of a cohort or panel study

Appraisal of a case control study

Appraisal of a survey

Appraisal of a qualitative study

Appraisal of a case study